Page 1
Quality Systems for the Clinical Laboratory Prepared by a CSLT Working Group CJMT Volume 57 # 2, Supplement
Page 2
INDEX
- The emerging importance of the total quality concept 2.Princlples of Total Quality Management 2
- Prerequlsltes for Implementing TQM within the laboratory 4
- Indlcators in TQM 5
- What TQM Implles for roles In the clinical laboratory 6 References 7 Figures
- The elements of quality systems
- Total Quallty Management: at the Laboratory Level 5 Appendices A.TQM termlnology B. One hospltal’s approach to qualty indicators C. Selected bibllography
Page 3
Quality Systems for the Clinical Laboratory T his information paper has been prepared by a Working Group of the CSLT, to provide an overview for laboratory technologists and managers of how and why quality systems are evolving in health care facilities in Canada. It is not intended to be a definitive work on quality management,orto follow any one particular philosophy.Itprovides an introduction to concepts of quality management within a health care context and relates them to the clinical laboratory.
- THE EMERGING IMPORTANCE OF What Is Quality? THE TOTAL QUALITY CONCEPT Within the TQM model, the achievement of quality is a The development of systems leading to improved quality continuous process involving all personnel at all levels of an in health care has been evolving rapidly since the late seven- organization in the pursuit of excellence in every process, ties and eighties.Stimulated by accreditation agencies and with the ultimate objective being quality patient care. Quality American initiatives, Canadian health care facilities began to is defined as consistently providing services which will meet implement quality assurance programs. During this period, or exceed the needs of our customers. What is different about quality assurance was extended beyond quality control activi- this definition of quality is that the perception of quality for ties to include all of the elements required to offer a service. the customer (in health care, the ultimate customer is the The success of a process was measured by comparing actual patient) is not solely based upon the technical and profes- performance against that deemed acceptable. Within the QA sional considerations which have in the past defined quality. model,quality was usually defined as the performance TQM ensures that along with technical criteria and standards, achieved through the adoption of extermal and internal stand- a facility focuses on the customer’s expectations of what ards. Inspection and problem resolution provided the focus constitutes a quality service. For a patient, factors such as for QA activities. These programs were primarily department perceived competence,reputation of a facility, waiting time, specific, and rarely addressed the interaction of the various and other impressions will strongly influence perception of departments involved in the overall delivery of health care. the level of service received. The patient may perceive the Programs were essentially organized along functional lines, level of quality as that which must be in place to ensure safe which meant that problem solving was often one dimen- care (the expected level) or one level above (the requested sional, and involved limited employee participation. New Jevel). If the quality of service is above that expected or approaches were required in the 1990’s to address the proac- requested, the patient may be delighted that the service has tive improvement of quality in health delivery systems. exceeded expectations. While it is appropriate that most of Added to these issues is the current focus on resource man- our resources be directed to ensuring that at least the expected agement within health care, and the search for new ways of level of quality is achieved, rising customer expectations managing the system which will preserve quality of care provide the dynamic for the continuous improvement of while providing affordability. quality. Here we have addressed the term “customer” from the per- spective of our primary customer, the patient,but it is impor- Contributors tant to note that in TQM the concept of “customerexpands well beyond the common interpretation (patients and their Dawn Ogram BA.ART families) to include staff and others who receive service from Joseph Hon MHSc,ART (Project Coordinator) the laboratory.Forexample, students would be the customers Patricia Likely-Regan of a laboratory training program, and total quality manage- Joan Lailey ART BSc,RT ment of the program would entail monitoring indicators of KentRondeau MA,MBA, Zoe Brooks ART student satisfaction with the training received. RT Mariette Parent MSc Staff resource person:Valerie Booth CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT
Page 4
Quaiity Systems for Ciinicai Laboratories supportive and facilitative environment to permit staff to The Context For Change excel. Change in the way health care facilities are being managed is being driven by several issues: 1.5 Elimination of Departmental Boundaries: Departmental and functional boundaries are being dis- 1.1 Industry Experience: solved with the adoption of program management, where all Quality initiatives and their success in industry have had an the needs of a particular patient group are addressed within important impact on expectations in all service areas, includ- the program. This reflects the multidisciplinary approach to ing health care. The importance of customer satisfaction health care delivery advocated within the CCHSA standards, necessitates revision of the way in which provision of service and which is the hallmark of the TQM concept. to patients and other customers has been managed in the past. 2. PRINCIPLES OF TOTAL QUALITY 1.2 Patient Expectations: Paternalism that has existed within health care has de- MANAGEMENT creased as patients have become more knowledgeable and Total quality management in the health care context has have demanded greater involvement in decisions concerning been defined by Phillip Hassan of St.Joseph’s Health Centre health care and treatment options. in London, as “providing the best possible care through continuously improving services to meet or exceed the ex- 1.3 CCHSA Standards: pectations of patients, physicians, staff and the community” It is generally accepted that for quality to exist there must through the adoption of several principles within the health be close collaboration between the numerous individuals and care facility. professions providing the services. This is reflected in the Berwick, Godfrey and Roessner? have outlined several changing focus of health care accreditation systems. The Canadian Council for Heaith Services Accreditation lows: (CCHSA) has progressively modified its standards to reflect a. Productive work is accomplished through the organiza- the importance of integrated service delivery. The 1995 tion of processes. standards demonstrate a dramatic change away from stand- Within the process framework, each person will fulfil one ards specific to departments and functions toward what is of three roles: supplier,processor or customer. termed a “client centred” approach, which emphasizes the b. Quality management is customer centred. The focus is importance of partnerships and team effectiveness to promote not on quality as defined by the health care provider, but is the environment for continuous improvement of the quality on the perception of quality by the person for whom the of care and services. service is being provided. The CCHSA approach to evaluation of a facility’s pro- c.Defects are most likely to be the result of process grams will change dramatically as of 1995. In place of problems than they are people problems. assessment of the compliance of individual departments with specific standards, surveyors will interview interdisciplinary d. There is a cost assoclated with poor quality. This care teams. Standards for these teams will focus on each stage includes detection costs (required to monitor processes to of the client’s care within the service, and will permit the identify defects), the cost of correcting the problem once surveyors to assess the effectiveness with which the health identified (for exampie, the cost of repeating a test run),and care team is able to deliver health care of continuity and costs associated with producing what is perceived to be a quality. sub-standard product. The goal is to ensure that processes are While the CCHSA does not endorse any specific manage- perforrmed correctly each time so that errors and rework are ment philosophy,it will be necessary for a facility to demon- avoided. strate that it is capable of providing the integration of e.There is predictable variation within every process. professional teams necessary to produce successful patient Understanding this is essential to improving performance and outcomes. This means that laboratory staff are being increas- for ensuring realistic quality initiatives that do not lead to an ingly called upon to move outside their own departments and even more unstable, unpredictable system. work with other professionals. Many facilities have chosen f. The focus of quality management initiatives should be on to adopt some form of quality management to provide the the most important areas in a process (those which are the framework within which these teams operate. most problematic,or are high risk or high volume). g. Quality management is based upon scientific method 1.4 Accountabllity: which requires a more rigorous approach to problem solving. Partially driven by economic constraints and reduced fund- Decisions are based on the analysis of data, which assumes ing in health care,health care facility management has begun (optimistically,Berwick notes) that measurement of a proc- to reflect the need for each individual within a team to be ess is always possibie, and that terms such as “morale”, accountable for his/her activities. Organizational hierarchies “satisfaction” and “reliability”may be “translated into opera- are flattening, and the role of managers has begun to shift tional measurements through carefully designed quantitative away from that of decision maker to one which provides a questionnaires”. CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT
Page 5
Quality Systems for Clinical Laboratorles h. The total involvement of every employee is essential at Comparing Quallty Assurance and Quaiity every stage of a process: planning, implementation, and Management: execution. The following table summarizes distinctions between qual- i. There are three components of quality management: ity assurance and quality management: quality planning, quality control and quality improve- ment. Quality planning involves defining what the customer Quality Assurance Quality Management requires, designing the processes to meet established goals and implementing these processes. Quality control involves Externally driven the maintenance of a process at target levels of performance Internally driven (or what has in the past been called QC and QA in the laboratory). Quality improvement describes the process un- Follows organizational Follows patient care dertaken to lead to improvement of the existing level of structure performance. These important points are summarized in a publication by Focused on problems/ Focused on processes/ the Canadian Psychological Association entitled “Total individuals systems Quality Management for Psychology Services in Health Care Facilities”: Works to endpoints “Total Quality Management, as currently practised, rests Has no endpoints on several basic principles: 1.Productive work is accomplished through processes, “Assures” quality Improves quality with each person receiving the work of others, adding to it, and providing it to the next person in the process. Centralized Part of everyone’s job 2. Threats to quality arise most commonly from problems in theprocesses of services delivery,rather than the individu Poorly coordinated/ Organization-wide als involved in it. fragmented 3.Quality depends on sound and explicit relationships among suppliers, providers and customers. Little top management Top management lead 4. Managing quality is the business of everyone in the involvement organization or system.” TQM and the Leadership Phllosophy: In simple terms, the relationship between our current QA The adoption of the principles of quality management plans and the approach suggested by TQM is as follows: involves a change in leadership that is best illustrated through a comparison of traditional management and total quality While many of our QA goals are outcome oriented, TQM management. Top level management’s endorsement of and active Involvement in the total quality management requires that we be more explicit in linking our activities process Is a prerequisite to successful implementation of to customer requirements. TQM within a facility or department.The practice of TQM Client satisfaction surveys have always been important, requires a very different approach to management. but the emphasis will now be on feedback which allows proving our processes. Traditional Leadership TQM Leadership tems: it is necessary to focus on the ways in which these various systems interact with each other, as well as the way Central, hierarchical control Coordination,facilitation in which our individual service functions. integration · In the past we focused on meeting predetermined stand- ards: if these were met, the service was assumed to be Central leadership Leadership shifts to operating at a quality level. This implied a static system, empower people, groups rather than the TQM notion that any service,no matter how effective, can be improved. We no longer wait until Plan, Direct, Control Coach, facilitate, listen, a standard is not met to work on improving the quality of develop a process or service. Within the TQM philosophy, problems and deficiencies represent value, in that they are opportunities for mprove- ment, which is quite a different perspective from that in traditional systems. CJMTVOLUME57 #2,SUPPLEMENT
Page 6
Quality Systems for Clinicai Laboratories assurance activities intersect with quality improvement proc- · Finally, TQM does not replace QA programs: these be- esses the areas are more fluid, for example: outcome meas- come the monitors for the continuous quality improvement ures of quality are modified by continuous improvement approach. It will still be necessary to provide ongoing teams. evidence that quality standards are being met. However, The area intersection of quality assurance, risk management our QA programs are likely to become more fluid as and quality improvement includes activities such as practice quality improvement initiatives enable us to exceed many guidelines, quality indicators and utilization management. of our predetermined standards, and encourage us to press beyond current levels of performance. (See Appendix A for definitions). How The Total Quality Approach Relates to 3.PREREQUISITES FOR IMPLEMENTING Existing Hospitai Programs TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT WITHIN The diagram below illustrates the interrelationships be- THE LABORATORY tween the various aspects of total quality management. The The following steps provide a framework within which diagram has been constructed to illustrate the more static aspects of quality management: quality assurance, quality basic TQM concepts may be implemented within the clinical improvement and risk management. laboratory: Traditional quality assurance includes equipment mainte-
- Define the principal functions for the Laboratory. These nance, quality control, policies and procedures, and many of have in the past been set forth in the laboratory mission the structural aspects of quality programs. Where quality statement. The Elements of Quality Systems QA Adherence to Predetermined Standards -staff -facility -equipment Outcome Quality Professional Standards Measures Safety Standards Practice Guidelines Utilization Management Customer Satisfaction Risk Teams Quality Indicators Resource Management Risk Identification Quality Teams RM Quality Circles Quality Improvement Risk Tools and Techniques Reduction Planning for Improvement Compliance with Legislation CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT
Page 7
Quallty Systems for Ciinicai Laboratories 2. For each of these principal functions, identify the suppli- The diagram below illustrates how these steps incorporate ers and customers, and linkages between them. the Deming P(lan)-D(o)-C(heck)-A(ct) cycle², and also illus- 3. Identify areas which are high risk, high volume and/or problem prone. quality teams fit within the TQM process. It should be noted 4. Set service and performance expectations in line with that this process is equally relevant to the department level professional standards and CCHSA requirements. Within the initiative as it is to an organization wide implementation. While it is beyond the scope of this discussion paper to expectations of customers, suppliers and providers, and iden- explore in depth each of these steps, the following sections tify the short and long range goals required to meet or exceed will address two of the critical factors in successfully imple- these performance expectations. menting a TQM approach: establishing indicators of quality, 5.Develop indicators to monitor the quality of service and the importance of teamwork in TQM. provided, with special emphasis upon the linkages between providers, suppliers and customers, and high risk,high vol- 4.INDICATORS IN TQM ume and problem prone areas. Define thresholds for these indicators, establish the frequency of monitoring for each. An indicator is defined by the Joint Commission on the Implement. Accreditation of Health Care Organizations as a“quantitative 6.Develop a plan that meets customer requirements. This measure that can be used as a guide to monitor and evaluate step is equivalent to the annual goals and objectives devel- the quality of important patient care and support service oped by the laboratory,but within the TQM model thefocus activities. An indicator is not a direct measure of quality. will be on what our customers have identified as important. Rather it is a screen or flag that identifies or directs attention 7.Implement the plan, and solicit feedback from your to specific performance issues that should be the subject of customers. 8. Use this feedback to further refine processes and to Laboratory medicine quality assurance plans and risk man- identify new important initiatives. agement programs have for years incorporated indicators used to establish whether processes are on track and perform- Total Quallty Management: at the Laboratory Level Use feedback to improve, pian new Lab mission/ important initiatives Goai Obtain feedback identify major from customers functions of the services Quality Teams identify priority functions: High risk, High volume, probiem prone implement Pian Identify the customers of these services Set plan to meet customers Set Quality expectation Indicators The continuous Quaity planning in the department: the foundation of improvement Cycle Quality Improvement CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT 5
Page 8
Quality Systems for Cilnical Laboratorles terms of interpretation of the results of testing, and therefore ing as designed, and for flagging those areas where special present the potential for errors that could impact patient care. attention may be required to maintain a system at defined In addition to these areas of focus,it is appropriate that in levels of service (or at a defined level of quality).Many of our earlier indicators were structure and process indicators, these resource strapped times, high cost areas are closely which reflected a more departmental approach to quality monitored: resources spent unwisely are not available for essential patient care. Resource management has a very real assurance. The focus on total quality management has led to the development of cross-functional indicators capable of impact on patient care. identifying problems within systems,as opposed to within distinct functions. Consequently, these indicators will focus Setting the Threshoid of Indlcators to a greater degree upon the impact of system failures on the Setting the threshold of an indicator is as important as customer. In the interest of resource management, it will be selecting the appropriate indicator. It is important that the important that TQM efforts be concentrated on areas which threshold be set at a level which will ensure that it actively will have the greatest impact on patient care. In summary, signals defects. In many cases this will require an interim appropriate monitoring of laboratory services requires in- period in which the initial threshold is based upon the best dictors that are: available data,the best current standards,and in some cases may be based on the “best guess”. What is important is that ·Meaningful to your setting as more data becomes available, the threshold level should be modified or fine tuned. It is also important to note that the · Clinically relevant fact that an indicator does not signal a quality problem does OOriented to problem and/or high volume procedures not mean one does not exist. Lab staff must constantly apply a common sense evaluative process (reality check) to the O Relatively easy to monitor (ie. should have an economical monitoring of laboratory data.While indicators provide the methodology) background monitoring required for major processes, there is no substitute for human interpretation of the relevance of Approach to Establishing Appropriate Indicators monitoring procedures. of Quailty Several examples of indicators are included in the appendix Establishing indicators that are patient care focused re- to this paper. quires that the laboratory identify which processes most impact the outcome of medical care received. 5.WHAT TQM IMPLIES FOR ROLES IN Indicators should monitor the most important aspects of THE CLINICAL LABORATORY what a department does, with an emphasis upon procedures which are high risk, high volume,and/or problem prone. The trend toward quality management entails a revision of High risk procedures are those which, if not present for the roles within the laboratory. This new way of managing re- support of specific patient groups (diagnostically or for ther- quires that the role of laboratory manager evolve from that of manager/decision maker, to that of facilitator/coordinator. ple would be STAT testing, or processes which due to their The manager’s primary role is gradually emerging as one critical nature and their substantial risk to patient care must which establishes the environment and facilitates availability have a defect rate of zero.Preparation of blood for transfusion of resources to enable individuals and teams to function most would be one area, as would blood gas analysis. High effectively.What we are also seeing is a flattening of man- volume procedures would be expected to impact the greatest agement layers, which have in many situations been viewed number of patients,and would therefore be an important area as detrimental to responsive problem solving. If many dif- to monitor. Examples would be complete blood counts and ferent levels are involved to obtain approval for relatively electrolytes. The term problem prone describes those proc- minor changes, then the change process itself has become the esses which may be problematic in terms of the process or in Old Roles New Roles Manager Directs Facilitates/obtains resources, sets general direction for department, functions collaboratively with staff; Team member; coordinates activities of various teams; Empowers teams to resolve problems; coaches, develops staff. Technologist Testing Problem solving/system design Team member, fully accountable for actions, professional scope of practice. CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT 6
Page 9
Quality Systems for Clinlcal Laboratories defining element of control in the hierarchy, a situation not 3. A new leadership philosophy: tapping into the expertise conducive to optimal performance. of each memberof the team to achieve service improvements. 4.Recognition ofthe importance ofinterdisciplinary and/or The Concept of Teamwork multidisciplinary collaboration: closing the gaps in our exist- The most significant change for employees within a facility ingQAprograms and ensuring that quality is defined in terms that chooses to adopt the principles of Total Quality Manage- of the broad experience of patients receiving health care. ment is their more specific involvement in what has pre- 5. Taking advantage of staff development in the use of team viously been considered the realm of management. In the past tools to provide teams the opportunities to be successful in the role of management has been to set direction, control, collaborative projects. define policies and procedures,and so on,and in many cases 6. Demonstrating perseverance and commitment to quality improvement. Giving the process time to demonstrate suc- isolation,sometimes with employee input. Within the frame- cess. work of Quality Management exists the recognition that The methods and tools used to accomplish the transforma- frontline staff are in an ideal position to provide input to tion from quality assurance to TQM are various. The impor- operational improvement While more progressive managers tant point for laboratory professionals is to ensure that our have recognised the value of employee input for many years, plans are consistent with the total quality picture for patient the principles of TQM provide a framework within which that care. To do this will require collaboration, coordination and energy and expertise can be channelled. Particularly within communication between the various care givers with whom the clinical iaboratories process innovations and instrumen- we interact. It will also require recognition that no one health tation needs can be defined with far greater accuracy when care process stands alone: quality patient care requires an staff teams at the bench level are involved in more than a intersection of processes that ensures our ultimate customer, token way. What is also achieved by this important involve- the patient, of service that will meet expectations and will ment is the general buy-in for change that is so important to produce a successful outcome. the success of any project. Tools Used by Teams for Quallty Improvement Projects Implementation of the quality management systems re- REFERENCES quires the development of the skills that will enable individu-
- Canadian Council on Health Services Accreditation: A Client Centred als to work effectively together, to ensure process Accreditation Program,1995StandardsFramework. coordination and that improvement opportunities can be 2.Berwick Donald,Godfrey A.Blanton,Roessner Jane Curing Health Care: identified and addressed constructively.Whether teams are New Strategies for Quality Improvement (Jossey Bass:Oxford, 1990) p.32 addressing problems (often most obviously revealed through quality issues) or are working on areas where improvement Psychology Services in Health Care Facilities”, developed by the may be possible (efficiencies achieved or more effective care CPA/CCHFA TaskForcenQuality inHealthCareFacilities,March,1993. 4.Fromberg R,The Joint Commission Guide to Quality Assurance: Chicago, provided),they can be most effective when provided with the The Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Institutions; 1988. training and tools to work collaboratively (team skills) and
- Bery Thomas,Managing the total quality transformation, McGraw Hill, the tools to collect, organize and focus data, which is an New York,1991. integral part of total quality management. 6.Ogram Dawn,CSLT Correspondence Course in TQM,March 1995. Case studies which illustrate use of various tools in labora- 7.Clark Gary,The JCAHO ten-step process selecting indicators of quality, tory projects will be published in upcoming issues of the Clinical Laboratory Management Review,July/Aug 1990. CJMT.
- Canadian Council on Health Facilities Accreditation: A Client Centred Accreditation Program,1995 Standards Framework. 9.Peters Tom,Thriving on Chaos,Harper &Row,(1987) SUMMARY This paper has outlined some of the factors which have given rise to the interest in TQM which is evidenced by changing accreditation requirements and widespread imple- mentation in health care facilities. Implementation of TQM in the clinical laboratory is dependent upon:
- A clear focus on the most important aspects of the service we provide,where if quality fails patient care wouid be most seriously effected high volume procedures,high risk and/or problem prone). 2.A focus on the customers of our services: ensuring that process improvements address their requirements. CJMTVOLUME57#2,SUPPLEMENT 7
Page 10
APPENDIX A TQM Terminology The following summarizes some of the TQM terms that are used in this paper. Customers/Suppiiers Empowerment The link between customer and supplier is central to the Providing employees with the opportunities, authority and TQM approach. To illustrate, consider the preparation of a resources to resolve quality issues in which they are directly blood component for transfusion. The technologist has sev- involved. eral suppliers: external suppliers such as the Red Cross for blood components, external supplier for reagents; internal Quaiity suppliers such as the blood collection team, nursing who The degree of adherence to a standard. Doing the appropri- providerequisition information,and thephysician who issues ate thing the appropriate way at the appropriate time. the order. The technologist is a customer of each,but aiso fulfils the role of supplier as the component of blood is issued Quaity improvement for transfusion. If at any stage within a process the supplier fails to provide what is required for the next person to Continuously improving our ability to meet and exceed appropriately complete the process, the quality of the end customer needs and expectations. product may be adversely affected. Risk Management Process A process may be described as a sequence of steps incor- net income, property, patients, residents, personnel or liabil- porating various inputs, applied through a variety of steps to ity of the facility.* produce outputs. The notion of variability within processes (and identifying when this variation can and when it cannot Utilization Management be improved or eliminated) is therefore an important concept The purpose of a utilization management program is to in the drive to continuously improve quality. plan, organize, direct and control the delivery of health care in a cost effective manner. Utilization management entails Indicator setting standards for efficient use of resources and acting to Measure used to monitor and evaluate the performance of ensure these standards are met.* important aspects of a service. *From the Canadian Medical Association Publication: Quality of Care: Issues and Challenges in the 90’s.
Page 11
s R Key to Indicator Categories: laboratory service is implicated specimen collection errors) in which g.#ENCON*reports (other than nature,time,etc) layed by incomplete requisition Sig- f.Number of blood gasreports de- e. Blood culture contamination rate contacted for critical result d. #Times physician could not be physicians/nursing staff C.Failure to call critical results to ciency testing b. Significant flags on external profi- a. Testing meets TAT standards 1.Indicator area:Provision of Clinically Useful Laboratory Irfornation The following ilustrates one hospital’s approach to quality indicators. It is provided as a sample but is not intended to be exhaustive. Structure Indicator Quality Indicator Risk Indicator Indicator TAT d (0) R(O) Q(O) R(O) R(O) Q(O) Q(O) Type Tumaround time Outcome Indicator Process Indicator Threshold DEPARTMENT OF LABORATORIES NORTH YORK BRANSON HOSPITAL N=O N=0 <4.0% N=O N=O 100% QUALITY INDICATOR REPORT:October,1994 Trended monthly Trended monthly review Threshold under October 94. New indicator: Trendedmonthly Broadcast report. againstSTAT notification logs Monthly audits of testing WellcomeProficiency Review of LPTP, TATaudits Procedure *ENCON reports = An extermal service for trending internal incident reports October conumence use in New indicator: October, 1994 conmence use New indicator: to October Range 1.33.3, January initiated daily Remedial action < 1% on daily log. September. shift substandard in Coag.testing and night Core lab implementation complete Results/Patterns None indicated Documentation on Critical Values log 1994to document remedial actions Formal log implemented October, None indicated Nov.1994 Actions/Timeframes Outcomes Appendix B
Page 12
s specifically monitored/trended in Each incident followed up with Actions/Timeframes documented remedial action, procedure/submission to be Trending to continue None indicated None indicated 94/95 Lab staff:3(13 in 1992) 18 errors for9 months. delay in on-line results. Blood gases: 11 (22 in Results: Jan to Oct’94 N=6.1(extrapolated One incident:16h absenteeism report) Results/Patterns fromOctober’94 Threshold to be New indicator, October 1994. $0.66 43.48 5.13% Unit staff:14 0 established 1992) %L> Incident report audits Reasons for rejections Audit of Lab Incident Number of incidents OHA Consolidation Report: Standard is mean of peer group OHA Consolidation Report: Standard is mean of peer group OHA Consolidation Report: Standard is mean of peer group Report”(quarterly) reviews,ENCON reports (quarterly) tracked through to be trended for Procedure specific remedial Incident report Verified Results Audit of”Edit (quarteriy) action Outcome Indicator Process Indicator N=5%
40.36 5.6% O=N N %60 %0 5% (Q(P) Q(P) (ao Q(O) Q(O) (00 (0)0 Type R(P) R(P) TAT P Resource Utilization b. Staff productivity (based on work- C. % Total function cost to total hos- e. # times test delayed >4h as a re- b. Lost specimens: S. Pathology a.Operating cost per total units (non-medical staff,supplies and d.Employee Absenteeism (Sick d.Computer data entry errors Key to Indicator Categories: Structure Indicator Quality Indicator a.Mislabelled specimens Risk Indicator Indicator C.Specimen rejections time) Days per year load units per hour) Indicator area: other expenses) pital cost time R Q s
Page 13
s Intensive inservicing to be conducted Nursing survey to be conducted in forProcurement Team in94/95. Actions/Timeframes be subject of study. November’94. 100%.All meters close 2Nursing complaints: to TAT on coagulation Results/Patterns 12%:Too long a wait one reiated toblood collection,the second 100%:November, 5%:Staff unfriendly 88%Technologist 100% 50% all staff %86 88%:Satisfied Structure Indicator to mean 1993 modified to reflect the This indicator will be assurance. Currently documented annually under development Training and written weeklyby Laboratory assessed annually for quarterly by category test:in November Satisfaction surveys Proof of licensure Complaints trended College (CMLTO) certification roster Audit of external program quarterly Audits conducted Procedure trends, potential standardsfor competence improvement TAT each year Review of areasfor staff
30% overall Quality Indicator Outcome Indicator N=O 100% 100% %001 95% %0 N=0 Coordination of Out-of-Laboratory Testing Type (s)o R(S) R(S) R(O) R(P) R(P) (0)0 (0)0 Satisfaction with Service Q O a. % of laboratory staff participating c.Workplace specific WHMIS train- functions not licensed with the Col- a. % of patient surveys that indicate b.# staff performing technologist a. Staff certifications completed to dissatisfaction with some aspect of b.#users dissatisfied with service b.All units where programs in c.Equipment used for testing is Key to Indicator Categories: Process Indicator Indicator quality controlled daily Risk Lndicator Indicator area: controlprogram Indicator area: in courses lab service schedule lege R P
Page 14
dropped since nurse managers routinely s Incidence has notified *C/T Ratio = crossmatch to transfusion ratio Incidence now monitored by Medical Audit and Tissue Committee Actions Timeframes occasion. 4/1119 exceeded 4h Results/Patterns Jan 94:3.1:1 ratio 100% 100% 100% Structure Indicator daily for products of partum blood groups Daily inventory check Daily inventory check audited for duration transfusion does not Lab incident report Daily Outstanding axa conception; post- Specimen report. Monthly trending Transfusions are Monthly report Procedure bedside check TAT (to confirm generated audited. audited audited audit Quality Indicator Outcome Indicator Threshold 100% %001 %0 OFN %001 100% O=N %0 Indicator area:Blood and Blood Products Lnventory R(S) R(P) R(O) (0)0 Type R(P) R(P) R(O) R(P) Q Indicator area:Transfusion Service Appropriate utilization of Transfu- a.Number of transfusion service in- cidents that had the potential to seri- b.Number of cases where the dispo- sition of blood issued from the Trans- in compliance with the CSTM Stand- dates for Rh-Immune Globulin were not identified,orphysician not noti c.Red Cross lookback for all blood d.Adherence to Blood Transfusion minimum stock,proper storage,ex- blood for autologous transfusion is bedside checks,including duraion sion service ensure the C/T Ratio fusion Service is not confirmed in of transfusion,are confirmedby e.Number of cases when candi- a.Inventory monitored daily for b.Storage and management of Key to Indicator Categories: can be traced to a recipient Process Indicator piry,signs of deterioration ousiy impact patient care Risk Indicator Indicator the Meditech System does notexceed3:1 laboratory staff RhIG. spe R P
Page 15
APPENDIX C Selected Bibliography RELATED BOOKS RELATED ARTICLES Al-Assaf AF,and Schmele JA. The Textbook of Total Quality in Banning J,Brown J, Hooper L, Hamilton J,Burnett J, Burnet L. Health Care.Delray Beach,Florida:St.Lucie Press. 1993. Quality Management Series: Reduction of Errors in Laboratory Test Berry TH. Managing the Total Quality Transformation. New Reports Using Continuous Quality Improvement Techniques. Clini- York:McGraw-Hill.1991. cal Laboratory Management Review 1993;7:424-436. Berstein SL and Hilbome LH. Clinical Indicators:The Road to Bounds G,Yorks L,Adams M, and Ranney G. Beyond Total Quality Care? The Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improve- Quality Management.New York:McGraw-Hill. 1994. ment 1993;19(11):501-509. Berwick DM, Godfrey AB,and Roessner J.Curing Health Care:New Strategies for Quality Improvement. San Fran- Berwick DM. Continuous Improvement as an Ideal in Health Care. cisco:Jossey-Bass.1991. Sounding Board.New England Journal of Medicine 1989:320:53- 56. Clemmer J. Firing on all Cylinders. Second Edition. Toronto:MacMillan Canada.1992, Bozzo PD. Conducting QI Studies that Effect Change.Medical Laboratory Observer 1992;24(10):39-42. Crosby PB.Quality is Free.New York:McGraw-Hill. 1979. Jahn M. Making the Grade on the Long Road to QI Medical Dean JW,Jr.and Evans JR. Total Quality:Management,Organiza- Laboratory Observer 1992;24(3):20-25. tion, and Strategy. St. Paul, Minnesota:West. 1994. Jahn M. How Straight is the Road to QI? Medical Laboratory Deming WE. Out of Crisis. Cambridge:Center for Advanced En- Observer 1992;24(3):26-29. gineering Study,Massachusetts Institute of Technology.1986. Laffel G and Blumenthal D. The Case for Using Industrial Quality Gaucher EJ and Coffey RJ. Total Quality in Health Care:From Management Science in Heaith Care Organizations. Journal of the Theory to Practice. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass. 1993. American Medical Association 1989;262:2869-2873. GOAL/QPC. The Memory Jogger:A Pocket Guide of Tools for Lumphrey D. TQM to the Rescue.Medical Laboratory Observer Continuous Improvement,Metheun,Massachusetts:GOAL/QPC. 1993;25(5):33-38. 1988. Menichino T. A Cost-of-Quality Model for a Hospital Laboratory. Hassen P.Rx for Hospitals:New Hope for Medicare in the Nineties, Medical Laboratory Observer 1992;24(1):47-50. Toronto:Stoddart.1993. Rakich JS, Darr K and Longest BB. An Integrated Model for Imai M. Kaizen:The Key to Japan’s Competitive Success. New Continuous Quality Improvement and Productivity Improvement in York:McGraw-Hill.1986. Health Service Organizations. Clinical Laboratory Management Juran JM and Gryna FM. Juran’s Quality Control Handbook. Review 1993;7(4):292-303. Fourth Edition.New York:McGraw-Hill. 1988. Ramirez O, and Lawhon J. Quality Improvement Team Uses FO- Leebov W and Ersoz CJ. The Health Care Managcr’s Guide to CUS-PDCA Method to Reduce Laboratory STAT Volume and Continuous Quality Improvement. Chicago: American Hospital Turmaround Time. Clinical Laboratory Management Review Publishing.1991. 1994;8(2):130-141. Leebov W and Scott G. Service Quality Improvement: The Cus- Schueing EE. Creating a Quality Culture in Your Organization. tomer Satisfaction Strategy for Health Care. Chicago:American Clinical Laboratory Management Review 1991;5(2):86-95. Hospital Publishing. 1994. Shaw PA. Launching Quality Improvement in Histology.Medical Melum MM and Sinioris MK. Total Quality Management:The Laboratory Observer 1993;25(3):45-49. Health Care Pioneers. Chicago:American Hospital Publishing. Simpson KN,Kaluzny AD and McLaughlin CP. Total Quality and 1992. the Management of Laboratories. Clinical Laboratory Management Omachonu VK and Ross JE. Principles of Totai Quality. Delray Review 1991;5(6):448-462. Beach,Florida:St Lucie Press.1994. Westgard JO,and Barry PL.Beyond Quality Assurance:Commit- Townsend PL and Gebhardt JE.Commit to Quality.New ting to Quality Improvement.Laboratory Medicine 1989;20:241- York:Wiley.1990. 247. Walton M.The Deming Management Method. New York:Perigree Westgard JO,and Barry PL. Total Quality Control:Evolution of Books.1988. Quality Systems in Health Care Laboratories. Laboratory Medicine 1989;20:377-384. Westgard JO, Barry PL, and Tomar RH. Implementing Total Quality Management (TQM) in Healthcare Laboratories. Clinical Laboratory Management Review 1991;5(5):353-370. Winsten D, and Vanderslice LM (1992).Boost QI Efforts with Expert Technology.Medical Laboratory Observer 1992;24(12):50 51.